top of page
  • High Bar Roofing

Composition Shingles vs Asphalt

It’s time to replace your worn-out roof, and you’re torn between composition shingles and asphalt. Maybe you’re installing a new roof and finding it difficult to decide the best roof that’ll protect your building for years.

In this composition shingles vs asphalt post, we’ll dig deep to determine the similarities or differences between the two.

Composition shingles vs asphalt - differences and similarities

There’s no difference between composition shingles and asphalt shingles. They are the same.

However, composition shingles are different from the original asphalt shingles that became widely used in the 1920s due to their easy installation and low price compared to other options such as slate. They are called composition shingles because they are composed of fiberglass base, synthetic coating, and covered with asphalt and granules.

The original asphalt shingles are made of wood, paper, or felt base and covered in asphalt. However, they are now phased out, and you probably won’t find them in use.

Pros and Cons

  • Pricing

Compared to others, composition shingles are the most cost-effective roofing option available today. Easily accessible, composite shingles are also very easy to replace.

  • Durability

Composite shingles are very durable. This is because they do not get affected by UV rays and resist mold and fungal growth. Also, composite shingles do not get affected by fire.

  • Options

You have a lot of color, style, and design options when you choose composite shingles, enabling you to customize your roofing to your taste.

Composition shingle types

Laminate, 3-tab, and luxury are the three types of composition shingles available, with each varying in design and price.

  • 3-tab

3-tab shingles appear to have three tabs on each strip of shingles, where they got their name. They are the standard composition shingle and are more common than the others. They are the least expensive and generally last for around 25 years.

  • Laminate

These are also known as architectural or dimensional. Laminate shingles are characterized by their random pattern and shadow lines. They are an upgraded version of 3-tan shingles and can last up to 30 years without a single leak.

  • Luxury

They are also called slate roofs because they look like slate tiles and wood shakes. Luxury shingles are larger and thicker than the other two composite shingles. Due to their thickness, luxury shingles can last up to 50 years without a single leakage.

Which shingle type is the best?

Lasting up to 50 years, with some having a lifetime warranty, luxury shingles are the best type of composite or asphalt shingles. Although composite shingles are popular due to their affordability, easy installation, and relative durability, slate and metal are the longest-lasting roofing materials.

Choosing your roof shingle

When choosing a composite shingle, you want to consider the protection, style, and color that works best for your property. A Fort Worth roofing expert will be able to guide you through the options so you can make the right choice.

Contact the Fort Worth roofing expert today!

There you go! The composition shingles vs asphalt comparison. Now you know the similarities and differences between them, the composition shingle types available, and how long they last.

Decided to install composition shingles and looking for a professional Fort Worth roofing contractor for a job done right the first time at the most competitive pricing? Contact High Bar Roofing and Construction today.

We’ll work with you to determine the best shingle that’ll enhance the aesthetic of your home and last long for your roof. Request an estimate to get started!


bottom of page